"Moral indignation:
jealousy with a halo."
--H.G. Wells
How did that come up? Following more fun hijinks on Fandom Wank, this time about a certain gentleman named Lee Goldberg who apparently thinks fanfic writers are Satan, or at least on the same level as muggers and rapists.
Step this way for the wank!He went into vitriol-spewing mode after discovering
OTW, whose birth I sort of witnessed here on LJ but whose organizers seem to have come down with a mild case of the batshit crazies (guess that sort of thing is contagious). The whole thing arose after the great Strikethrough Debacle here at LJ, paired with some hatred of FanLib.com and its ohnoes! mercenary bent. (I think FanLib sucks and don't post there, but that's just me.) At first people were simply talking about coming up with a large, multi-fandom archive with the great technical features of ff.n without all the asshattery and serial systems failures. I thought that was a great idea. However...
...now it seems almost as if the founders of OTW want to say that fanfiction and fanfic writers have equal rights when it comes to copyright, etc., basing their whole argument on the idea that fic (and fanvids and fanart) are transformative rather than derivative in nature. Not only do I not agree with that position (yes, fanfic, art, etc. may transform certain events, characters, and what-have-you, but at bottom it still has been derived from a source work), but I also think the gals at OTW (who claim that fandom is mostly female and feminist...guess that writes off all the guys I knew at theforce.net who write Star Wars fics) might as well have painted a bulls-eye on fanfic writers. We get ignored because (with a few notable exceptions, who were quickly stomped on) we know the rules. We don't try to make a profit off our work. We give credit to the original creators of the novel/film/TV series/anime our fics are based on. But if we try to claim that we have an equal footing with the creators of those work...well, then, I can see that opening a nasty can of sand worms.
I love writing fanfic (obviously). It allows me to explore ideas and concepts the original writers either never got around to or which are simply too "out there" in terms of how the characters were visualized by their creators to have ever been written by those authors. I know I've learned a lot about writing during the past three and a half years, which is about how long I've been writing fics (except for
Dust of Empire, which was started many years earlier but abandoned for a goodly span of time). I think it's a valid form of writing -- at least the thoughtful, well-researched stories that help to expand the authors'/creators' original worlds. Derivative literature, whether it's
Wide Sargasso Sea,
Wicked, or
'Til We Have Faces, is accepted in literary circles...as long as it's based on work that's out of copyright. So do people like Lee Goldberg only hate fanfiction simply because it's a threat to copyright, and not because it lacks artistic merit? To hear him argue it, he'd say he hates it for both reasons. But I get the impression it's more because he's afraid it might hit him where it hurts, in the wallet (he writes tie-in novels for TV series such as
Monk). I guess what he does is all right because even though it's derivative, he has a contract from the studio to do so. Following that line of thought, I guess he'd hate
Dust of Empire up until the moment Lucasfilm Ltd. decided to license it. :-P
I don't know where all this is going to end up. Part of me is really hoping that OTW dies on the vine, because I could see that organization stirring up a shit-ton of trouble for those of us who are in it just for fun. But even if the whole sorry mess results in lawsuits and crackdowns on fic archives, I won't stop writing my stories, even if they end up being just for me (well, me and anyone who wants me to email the updates to them). It would be a sad day, though, and I hope it never comes.